Choosing a trustworthy journal

Predatory journals charge authors fees, but offer little or no peer review, editorial oversight, or long-term archiving. Publishing in a predatory journal can damage your reputation and the work may not count towards future funding or job applications. New researchers are often targeted by these publications, so it is worth checking before you submit a paper to a title unknown to you.

Some warning signs to look out for:
  • An unsolicited email inviting you to submit, often with flattering language
  • Promising a very fast peer review (eg, days rather than weeks)
  • Unclear or hidden article processing charges (APCs), or fees that are only revealed after acceptance
  • A journal title that closely imitates a well-known one
  • No named editorial board, or, if they are named, some board members don’t know they’re listed
  • Vague scope or claims to cover an implausibly wide range of subjects
  • Poor English grammar in the invitation to submit, broken links in the message or on the website, or a generic email address (Gmail, Yahoo) for editorial contact
  • Claims of impact factors or indexing that you can’t verify
How to check journal titles:
  1. If the journal claims to be open access, look it up in the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) and check whether it is indexed in databases such as Scopus or Web of Science.
  2. Search for the journal in the DHET list of accredited journals.
  3. Ask the librarian, or your supervisor, or a colleague whether they know the journal.